• The latest from the front lines of literature
  • No menu assigned
FSG | Work in progress
Close Search
  • Home
  • Archive
  • 01.31.13
    The Problem with Aesthetic Violence

    The Problem with Aesthetic Violence

    On Disney, David Lynch, and Django Unchained by Eric G. Wilson In the weeks after the Sandy Hook Elementary School killings, Quentin Tarantino’s Django Unchained—which depicts a freed American slave taking bloody revenge on cruel slaveholders—has faced a lot of media scrutiny. Pundits have wondered if this kind of fictional brutality incites real-life violence. It’s a debate that seems to resurface every few years, but in this case the ideologues can save their energy: Django Unchained is more harmless and reassuring than most old-time Disney flicks. Beside it, Bambi is like a noirish nightmare. Tarantino’s gore fulfills our moral fantasies. It’s innocuous commotion setting up, and acting as a foil for, a soothing conclusion in which the good are rewarded and the evil are punished. And the more horrific the brutality, the more gratifying the reckoning. Compared to the slaughter of Bambi’s mother, never avenged, this kind of closure is pure Pollyanna. Tarantino has been careful to distinguish between the artificial violence of his films and actual carnage. In an interview on NPR, he claimed that viewers are tired of movies on slavery or the Holocaust that depict only pain. They welcome fiction in which the victims rise up to be “the victors and the avengers,” “paying back blood for blood.” This aesthetic violence is “cathartic,” “good for the soul.”

    READ MORE
© 2023 FSG Work In Progress FSG Books | Ads and Cookies | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Notice | Your Privacy Choices
  • Home
  • Dare to Imagine
  • Essays
  • In Conversation
  • Excerpts
  • Poetry
  • On Writing
  • On Writers
  • Book Recommendations
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Search
    The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.